Amy Conley

Conley & Partners Team Leader | REALTOR®

M: 614-595-4344

Contact Me My Website

Make Preferred Realtor
Amy Conley - Cutler Real Estate Agent


Buyer's Agent, Condominiums, Listing Agent, Luxury Homes, New Construction, Relocation, Residential




Dog Lover, Family, Foodie, Skiing, Traveling


Cutler Real Estate asked Amy a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Amy's replies.

1. What is your professional/educational background?

Bachelors in Business

2. Why did you choose a career in real estate?

I followed in my mothers footsteps

3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live?

I just moved recently!  I now reside in Bexley -- an older walk-able community in Columbus. Previously I lived in German Village.

4. How do you spend your free time?

With family and friends and traveling if I can find the time

5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be?

  1. My family
  2. Friends
  3. Dogs

6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you?

Strong Work Ethic, Generous and Kind


Bexley, OH

Bexley is a suburban city near Columbus boasting gorgeous homes, plentiful green space and a tight-knit community. This historic neighborhood is home to the Governor’s Mansion, Jeffrey Park & Mansion, and a variety of local eateries and shops. Real Estate Bexley real estate includes an impressive collection of stately mansions and estate homes situated along tree-lined streets in quiet neighborhoods. Homes in Bexley are some of the most sought-after in the region, and the suburb is an exceptional and desirable area to call...

Learn More
Bexley - Photo 1

Dublin, OH

Located just 17 miles from downtown Columbus, Dublin is a lively suburb of the city with lots of natural space, golf courses, business headquarters, and more. This popular city is continually developing and expanding, and is an increasingly popular place to call home. Real Estate Dublin is primarily an affluent city filled with a variety of estate properties, many of which are situated in a pristine country club setting. Homes in Dublin range from modest single-story homes to grandiose properties on expansive lots. Dublin homes...

Learn More
Dublin - Photo 1

German Village, OH

Located just south of downtown Columbus, German Village is a charming neighborhood boasting historic homes, quaint local shops and eateries, and brick sidewalks and streets. This historic neighborhood is one of the most renowned communities in the country. Real Estate Featuring sturdy, red-brick homes along tree-lined brick streets, German Village is a desirable neighborhood to call home. Homes in German Village are typically situated close together on narrow plots with small yards. Due to the neighborhood’s charm and central...

Learn More
German Village - Photo 1
Be the first to add
a testimonial below
Add Testimonial
5/5 Based on 89 Ratings
View More Testimonials on Agent Site
Jun 5, 2020

This was our first time buying a home and Amy was our trusted advisor every step of the way. Moving from out of state, she showed us around all of Columbus, including various neighborhoods, landmarks, restaurants, attractions. She quickly learned our likes/dislikes in style and made the whole process for home buying so easy for us. We never felt pressured. She was honest with her opinions of each house. She and her team were very responsive and kept us on track with all the paperwork. Plus she was just fun to hang out with! Thank you Amy for helping us find our first family home!

— Diana Vo
Jun 3, 2020

Amy and her staff are AWESOME!! She made our family feel so welcome and comfortable during the stressful process of planning a move from far away and finding the perfect home for us. She was so attentive and kind throughout the entire process. I already feel I know so much about Columbus and its suburbs- thank you so much Amy - and thank you for helping us find our perfect home.

— chillios1
May 27, 2020

Amy is extremely knowledgeable of the industry and efficient in her work. She was very considerate of the tenant during the sale also which I know they appreciated.

— sixandrews2
Apr 8, 2020

Working with Amy was a wonderful experience and we would highly recommend her. She knew exactly what we were looking for and identified a home that we really liked. Her extensive knowledge of the the Columbus market and more specifically the Bexley neighborhood was very helpful. She made the process of purchasing our home as seamless as possible. She is a true professional who really cares about finding her clients the perfect home. We could not be more pleased with the home she found us, but also the experience of working with Amy from start to finish! If you are looking for a realtor, Amy is truly the best of the best in Columbus! A true professional and expert who truly cares about her clients.

— user42328099
Mar 21, 2020

Amy and her team are incredible to work with! Amy is extremely knowledgable, helpful and professional. Her team kept everything organized behind the scenes and it all led to a seamless process for us. We have referred Amy many times in the past to friends and co-workers and will continue doing so!

— katierapp32
Mar 13, 2020

Amy is the best. She takes the time to understand the needs of her customers and finds the best house for them. She knows how to write the offer that will get accepted.

Mar 4, 2020

Since the outset of our mission to find a home, Amy has been exceptionally WONDERFUL and extremely helpful with the search! She has gone above and beyond with the entire process ... relentless ... until we found our home! Her expertise, her knowledge, and her kindness and compassion for her clients and her work are what make Amy a one-of-a-kind Real Estate Professional. Many thanks to Amy and her colleagues/staff for all they have done! [ Pat and Susie F ]

— susiept357
Jan 7, 2020

Great suggestions and timing. We were going to wait until after the Holidays and list it in January. On Wednesday Dec 18, 2019 Jean Ann suggest that we list it on Friday Dec 20th. It was listed and had a contract the same day. Closed 7 days later. Very seamless and organized. Outstanding!

— user97395749
Sep 17, 2019

Amy was fantastic to work with! As a first time seller, she was so patient answering all of my questions. It was very easy to communicate with her and her team via phone and email and I always got a prompt response from someone. So thankful to have worked with Amy and her team throughout this process!

— sarah ann houck
Aug 20, 2019

Amy knows the Dublin area market intimately and keeps a finger on its pulse. I have bought and sold two homes with the Conleys in the last several years and they do their best to make a sometimes frustrating experience pleasurable.

— 44tinsley
View More Testimonials on Agent Site